Waiting for Hollow Knight: Silksong felt like babysitting a kettle that had been promised to whistle for six years—then, when it finally did, it sprayed steam all over my kitchen and shorted the fuse box. That is my polite way of saying the September 4, 2025 launch was a beautiful mess. I was there, refreshing Steam like a raccoon staring at a vending machine, and for a while the storefront itself went down under the weight of everyone else doing exactly the same thing. Six years of silence from Team Cherry, one massive wishlist crown, and then—boom—servers wobbling, platforms wheezing, and a sequel that finally existed. In 2026, with the benefit of hindsight and several patches, the story looks much better than it did on day one. But oh, what a bumpy little silk road it was.
When the dust settled, Silksong landed at a ‘Very Positive’ Steam rating—about 93% positive out of roughly 126,000 user reviews. That is not a disaster. It is, however, the kind of number that makes a highly anticipated sequel feel like it showed up to its own birthday party wearing a slightly damp sweater. The original Hollow Knight sits at 97% from over 140,000 ratings, and Silksong 's initial Metacritic user score of 8.9 trailed the first game’s 9.1. For most games, that is excellent. For this game, it was enough to trigger a thousand sorrowful Steam essays beginning with some variation of ‘I really wanted to love this game.’ One user, Icarus IX, summed up the mood with the kind of blunt force that only a disappointed Metroidvania fan can deliver: 'Hollow Knight is a masterpiece. Silksong is
