The wait is over, but the verdict is not unanimous. After more than six years of anticipation, Hollow Knight: Silksong finally arrived and immediately became a cultural event: it was the most wishlisted game on Steam, storefronts buckled under demand, and the game reached a peak concurrent player count of roughly half a million. Yet the first wave of Steam user reviews tells a more complicated story. Silksong currently sits at a ‘Very Positive’ rating, with 94% of roughly 27,000 user ratings positive—just short of the 95% threshold needed for ‘Overwhelmingly Positive.’ For most games, that would be a triumph. For a sequel to Hollow Knight, a title with 97% positive ratings from more than 140,000 reviews, it is a signal that something has shifted. Is ‘Very Positive’ really a disappointment, or does it simply prove how impossible the expectations had become?

A Sequel Measured Against a Masterpiece

The numbers are close, and that is precisely the problem. Initial Metacritic user scores placed Silksong at 8.9, compared with Hollow Knight’s 9.1. On Steam, the gap between 94% and 97% positive may look small, but for a highly anticipated sequel, anything shy of greatness can feel underwhelming. Many negative reviews begin with the same wistful sentence: ‘I really wanted to love this game.’ Steam user Icarus IX put the mood bluntly: ‘Hollow Knight is a masterpiece. Silksong is not.’

Can any sequel escape the shadow of a predecessor that fans have spent years treating as untouchable? That question hangs over much of the early criticism. The disappointment is not that

dealnesthq